Thursday, January 7, 2010
The Book of Revelation and the Centrality and Power of the Gospel Alone
Silliest Thing I Have Read Today:
The "separation of roles [between ethnic Israel and the church] is a clear depiction of the continuing uniqueness of Israel and of the separateness of the church from Israel in God's plan. That distinctiveness of Israel is evident throughout the rest of the Bible, beginning in Genesis 12; and the church is separate from Israel throughout the New Testament. This will not change in Christ's eternal kingdom [heaven]".
*The brackets are my own words to clue you in on the context.*
Best Thing I Have Read Today:
"[T]he early church did not seem to be preoccupied with the specific timing of the completion of these end-time matters [when Christ would return again]. For it, the first coming of Christ was imbued with eschatalogical meaning, which was more than sufficient to sustain hope until the Parousia. As it turned out, the second coming of Christ was obviously delayed, but such postponement did not seem to dramatically unsettle the church. For the early Christians, the Parousia was an epilogue, albeit an important one, to the first coming of Christ".
Wednesday, December 23, 2009
Grace Chapel Blog on New Covenant Theology Website

Some random notes.......
Click here for an article written by a staunch New Covenant theologian who argues against the wisdom of Christians signing the Manhattan Declaration. His arguments are similar to the ones I have outlined from other noted men. He also answers some of the questions I proposed in an earlier blog article.
And on a lighter note, if you are a Rolling Stones fan, then click here to read an intersting article.
Grace and Peace,
Andy
Thursday, October 1, 2009
New Covenant Theology Interview of Gary Long
http://www.ptsco.org/jrginterviewofgl.htm
Monday, August 10, 2009
A Bird's Eye View of New Covenant Theology (Part 4)

Friday, August 7, 2009
A BIrd's Eye View of New Covenant Theology (Part 3)
DISTINCTIVES OF NCT (continued)Thursday, August 6, 2009
A Bird's Eye View of New Covenant Theology (Part 2)

When we looked at the "six principles" of NCT we laid down a good understanding of a few of its distinctions. However, let me use the next couple of posts to emphasize and clarify its most significant features. First, NCT differs from CT in its understanding of a supposed "covenant of grace" in Genesis 3. NCT is related to CT in one important sense. NCT does affirm that the "covenant" motif (or theme) seems to be emphasized in Scripture. However, NCT departs from CT on this very point at the same time. Allow me to explain. Rather than seeing a "covenant of grace" in Genesis 3 serving as the "father" of the covenants with many children following (Noahic, Abrahamic, Davidic covenants, etc.), NCT prefers to see (as stated before) the unfolding of God's revelation through biblical covenants progressively and gradually. In other words, NCT denies an over arching "covenant of grace" made in Genesis 3. Instead, NCT emphasizes the Abrahamic covenant. Indeed, one could almost call this covenant the true "covenant of grace" according to NCT proponents! In this covenant, Abraham believed God's gracious promise, and he was counted as righteous in God's eyes.
Second, NCT prefers the phrase "God's one eternal purpose", rather than the classic "covenant of redemption" to speak of God's electing grace determined before the foundation of the world (Ephesians 1). As the last statement made clear (I think), this does not mean that NCT denies God's role as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in "covenanting", or agreeing together as a unit to accomplish redemption for sinners. Again, this seems to be an issue of Biblical precision on the part of NCT, though in my study it seems that conceptually speaking NCT does not differ from CT at all on this point. In fact, I believe CT has an orthodox understanding of the Trinity in their affirmation of a covenant of redemption. I just believe they would do better to use the Biblical language such as "God's one eternal purpose", which is used in Ephesians 1 to describe the agreement among the members of the Godhead.
Here is a statement of faith according to NCT doctrine that expresses the idea of God determining to redeem man by use of the covenant format:
We believe that God has maintained one eternal purpose in Christ which has been expressed through a multiplicity of distinct historical covenants" (Solo Christo's Statement of Faith).
The above statement affirms the predetermined action of God to redeem sinners. In addition, it affirms that the revelation of this predetermined plan will take place through various covenants in the course of redemptive history.
That is enough for today. Next time we will look at some more distinctives.
Aiming to be Biblically Accurate,
Monday, August 3, 2009
A Bird's Eye View of New Covenant Theology
DEFINITIONS OF NCTAllow me to give you a handful of definitions for NCT. Interestingly, these are not really technical definitions. One can search high and low and he will not find a technical definition of NCT given by NCT adherents. Nevertheless, the statements below are quotes from various sources that I believe give to us a broad definition of NCT.
“New Covenant Theology (NCT) is a less settled theology than a movement still in the shaping by men who agree that the question has not yet been finally answered by either of the major competing schools of interpretation- dispensational theology and covenant theology…NCT claims simply to have middle ground between these two (DT and CT). We are not satisfied with the simple ‘one covenant’- ‘two administrations’ idea of CT. In our judgement this results in a rather ‘flat’ reading of Scripture which fails to appreciate the advance, the distinctively new character of the Messianic age. Nor are we satisfied with the over-compartmentalizing tendency of Dispensational theology. In our judgement its ‘no law’ and ‘two equal peoples’ notions failed to appreciate the unity of God’s nature and purpose. And so we find ourselves somewhere between the two traditional answers”.( Fred Zaspel, A Brief Explanation of New Covenant Theology).
If I can, allow me to point out a couple of features in Fred’s explanation of NCT. First, Fred speaks of NCT as more of a movement than a defined or settled system. This is important to grasp. I have found that there are many “streams”, if you will, of NCT. And not all of these “streams” converge into the same body of water. In fact, I recently asked Tom Wells (the foremost New Covenant Theologian) about this very topic. He was clear that all “streams” of NCT are not in complete agreement with one another. Quite frankly, it is even difficult to identify these streams. Suffice it to say, however, NCT is not as sharply defined as either DT or CT. This is not a criticism; it is a fact. It must be stated that this is also true with both DT and CT as well. There are many “streams” within each one of these systems. Nevertheless, it seems that with NCT the streams are more diverse, and are greater in number. However, it is difficult to know for sure. I do not know every dispensationalist, covenant theologian, and new covenant theologian. This is another reason why neither what others believe, nor logic itself should ever serve as the foundation to our belief systems. Scripture is the basis. And by the way, Scripture is logical (that is not to say that there are not mysteries found in paradox form), and Biblical truth will generally show itself in the majority positions of the church throughout church history.
Second, Fred speaks of NCT as holding a “middle ground” position between DT and CT. This is an important clarification. NCT does not take attributes of DT and place them in their system and then turn around and take elements of CT and store these in their system. Rather, NCT bases its arguments on Scripture. It is not a hodge-podge of DT and CT. Fred’s point is simply that in the final analysis NCT ends up somewhere between these other two systems of theology. Fred’s explanation serves in truly clarifying what we are facing with NCT.
Another way to define NCT is rooted in a short, pithy statement by a man I have yet to meet (but long to someday), John Reisinger. He once made the remark that, “Dispensationalism cannot get Israel and the church together in any sense whatsoever, and covenant theology cannot get them apart”. Essentially, Reisinger is affirming the failure of both DT and CT. Their failure is found in different aspects of the same topic- the identity of the church and national Israel. DT affirms that there are two peoples of God. Thus, they fail to define any unity in God’s elect people of all time. And CT, on the other hand, fails to separate Israel from the church. They view these two people as one entity. Reisinger’s point is that both positions are wrong. And the implication is that NCT holds the right answer. I agree with him and will seek to prove that in the remaining posts on NCT.
The next definition is take from Gary Long. He says, “NCT is a developing system of theology that provides a more biblical way to interpret the Scriptures by questioning key theological presuppositions which undergird the hermeneutics (principles of interpretation) of CT and DT” (Gary Long, New Covenant Theology Disnitctives). Gary Long is a strong NCT proponent. However, he refuses to “throw the baby out with the bath water” (sorry to use such a routine cliché). I appreciate his intellectual perceptiveness, and honesty of character to admit that not everything DT and CT teach is heretical and Satanic. Notice he says that NCT promotes " a more Biblical way" than either DT and CT. This is NCT being worked out practically- the demonstration of love toward others. He does not compromise truth. No, no! But he is also not condescending in his attitude.
One final way to understand NCT can be seen in the following statement:
“New Covenant Theology (NCT) describes how the unfolding plan of salvation in Scripture is to be understood. It focuses on the relationship between the Old and New Covenants. It views the nation of Israel as a picture of the people of God but not the believing people of God. It understands the Mosaic Covenant to be a legal covenant that demands perfect obedience in order to receive the promised blessings. It views the Ten Commandments as the essence of the Mosaic law and not the essence of all of God’s law. It views the New Covenant as a new and better covenant that replaces the Old Covenant. New Covenant Theology differs from both Covenant Theology and Dispensationalism” (Defining New Covenant Theology, Geoff Volker and Mike Adams from In Depth Studies).
Lord willing, we will look at some distinctives of NCT later.
Friday, July 31, 2009
The Role of the Holy Spirit as the 'Fuel" for the Role of the Believer
"Here are words Jesus said to His friends the night before He was killed, 'If you love me, you will obey what I command. I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Counselor to be with you for ever- the Spirit of truth...I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you' (John 14:15-18).
These words introduce us to a new power, the One called in Scripture 'the Holy Spirit'. Jesus spoke of the Spirit to offset the fears of His followers when they grasped the fact that He was going to leave them. They thought that if He were to go away all their hopes would be crushed. 'Not so!' said Jesus. 'Not at all!' Later that evening the Lord Jesus added, 'It is for your good that I am going away. Unless I go away, the Counselor will not come to you; but if I go, I will send him to you' (John 16:7).
The coming of the Spirit was of first importance to the disciples, although just then they could not have told you why. The reason was this. To this point in their Christian lives the disciples had depended upon the Lord Jesus to empower them. Jesus encouraged them and instructed them and counseled them and rebuked them when they needed it. They drew upon His wisdom and guidance to keep them going. His presence and ministry to them was the fuel for their own efforts. They could not imagine life without Him. It was unthinkable.
Now here is what is important. These disciples were right in thinking they could not live without the Lord Jesus. This was not a case of mere sentimentality. It struck far deeper than that. Their understanding was sound. They must have the Lord Jesus or die spiritually. It was a simple as that! Yet there He was, telling them to bid Him goodbye. Or so it seemed.
But the all-important fact was this: the Spirit, who was to come, was God also. Just as Jesus Christ is God, so the Holy Spirit is God. Yet while the friends of Jesus could no longer have His physical presence, they still needed His wisdom and guidance. They wanted the refreshment that His counsel had brought them. And these things the Spirit of God would give. The Spirit would take the place of Jesus as the Helper of His friends. He would be 'another Jesus'! He would not be with them visibly as Jesus had been, but He would live within them, 'the Spirit of truth' (John 14:16-17).
Now you must not think of this simply as history. It is history, of course. Jesus' first-century followers found that the Spirit came to them and supplied the place that the Lord Jesus had held among them. All of that is true. But what interests us is this: it happens today. In every age since the Lord Jesus returned to His Father in heaven, He has given His Spirit to His people. The gift of the Spirit sustains us. And, if you come to Christ, He will sustain you as well.
The Bible gives two answers when we ask the question, 'What is it that the Spirit does for believers?' We might call these 'an outside answer' and 'an inside answer'. By an 'outside answer' I mean that the Spirit has done something outside of us to help us greatly. I am thinking of His work in producing the Scriptures. Of course, that was a once-for-all work. I want to take it up later. Just now, however, it is the 'inside answer' on which I want to focus. A major part of the Spirit's work is within the believer. There He plants an inclination to obey and follow the teaching of the Scriptures that He has produced. This 'inside' work necessarily goes on through all the Christian's life. It is this that sustains him.
In the last chapter, I told you that Jesus will assert His lordship over your life if you become a Christian. That is certainly true; He does it with all who follow Him. I do not know what kind of vision that fact raised in your mind. Perhaps none at all. But it is just possible that I led you to think of the Lord Jesus as working against your own inclinations and crushing you into submission. That is not the case. The truth is far different.
The Lord Jesus asserts His lorsdship by sending His Spirit. It is the Spirit's work to give us a love for the ways of Christ. It is not a question of continually beating back the Christian's desires. There is no forcing the believer to be what he should be. That is not how God works. For one thing, there would be no end to that task. If we were not changed inwardly we would need to be pushed along throughout eternity. But that is not the picture the Bible gives us. Not at all!
The Spirit forms our attitudes; that is the main thing. It is not that actions are unimportant. We dare not ignore them. But attitudes lie behind sincere actions, so that is where the Spirit goes to work. Paul shows us the result in his letter to the Galatians. 'The fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control' (Gal. 5:22-23).
You do not get such 'fruit' by applying physical force. Love, joy, peace and the rest lie at the heart of what a man is. You must change the person to grow this fruit, and in this work the Spirit is continually engaged. We are commanded to have these fruits, these attitudes, in the Scriptures. And, as I have said, these same Scriptures were themselves produced by the Spirit. But He does not simply leave us with His commands. If we are Christians the Spirit gives us the desire to obey Him. In that way He makes these attitudes our own. His word outside us and His work within us go hand in hand."
The Spirit empowers His people to be obedient!
Summarizing New Covenant Theology (Part 3)
NCT’S PRINCIPLE OF REPRESENTATIONNCT places a strong emphasis on the type/anti-type dimensions of Scripture. The nation of Israel in the OT is seen as a type and promise. The church in the NT is seen as the anti-type and fulfillment. In other words, the church became what the nation of Israel never was, and never could be. This is not saying that the nation of Israel were not nationally elect. Nor is it denying that there were spiritually elect people of God residing in the Israelite community throughout history. It is simply arguing that from top to bottom and throughout their history, the nation of Israel rejected their status as “God’s people”. That is, they never obeyed God (nationally) as God intended them to and to the degree they themselves intended to obey God (Exodus 19:3-8). Logically, this does not necessitate a view that sees God as failing with His “first” people (Israel), and therefore reaching out to a “second” people (the church). NCT robustly holds to a view of God that emphasizes His sovereignty. And in God’s wise sovereignty He chose redemptive history to play out the way in which He did. As I write this blog I am going to do something that might be a little dangerous. Indeed, I might regret it later. But a thought just crossed my mind, and I want to share it with you. Here it is. I submit to you that the primary purpose of God nationally electing Israel is ultimately threefold: 1) to reveal His power and glory, 2) to show Israel, and the other nations throughout all time the exceeding sinfulness of man and his innate inability to ever obey God perfectly even after being placed in a “privileged and unique relationship” with God Himself, 3) to preserve a line for the Messiah (the Redeemer) to come.
Now this thing I simply call the principle of representation shows that NCT disagrees with DT, which affirms that there are two people of God. NCT would agree with CT that there are one, true people of God. On the other hand, NCT would disagree with CT that this one true people (known as the “Church”) existed in the Old Testament period. If this sounds rather confusing, just take a step back, breath deeply, and refocus. Let me provide something for you that might help.
Dispensationalism
Overview of redemptive history from God’s vantage point:
-I will choose a people to worship me. It will be Israel.
-This nation is rebellious. Thus, I will extend my hand of grace to those outside of Israel. This will be a separate entity made up of Jew and Gentile. It will be called the Church.
-However, I will remain faithful to my earlier promises to Israel. Thus, at the end of the day national Israel will worship Me.
Covenant Theology
Overview of redemptive history from God’s vantage point:
-I will choose a people to worship me. It will be Israel/the Church.
-When Christ comes my grace will extend to the nations and they will be joined to Israel/the Church. At this time the church will no longer be largely composed of Jews, but will include Gentiles.
New Covenant Theology
Overview of redemptive history from God’s vantage point:
-I will choose a people to worship Me. It will be Israel. They will not worship Me, and this is My very purpose in choosing them. When they refuse to worship Me, it will reveal to all men his need of Me.
-Within Israel I will preserve a remnant- those who will have faith in Me and worship Me; sincerely trusting in the same promise that Abraham did. From this people will come the true Israel- the Messiah-who will do what the nation never did. He will be perfectly obedient to My law.
-When Christ comes My grace will extend to the nations. This new entity made up of Jew and Gentile will be called the Church. They will be the true Israel, for they will exist in the "true Israel" (their Savior, Jesus Christ). For they will do what national Israel (the people I began with) never did- they will worship Me forever! I will empower them to do so!
Now let me give one more clarification to what NCT teaches. NCT does not deny that there were literal promises fulfilled in national Israel. However, NCT would largely argue that the land promises given to national Israel find their fulfillment (at least partly) in the new covenant inheritance of salvation (Ephesians 1:11; Colossians 1:12; I Peter 1:4).
Here is a way that helps me remember NCT:
One Promise- God will restore sinful man to relationship with His Creator.
One Person- Jesus Christ is the central figure in Scripture (not the people of Israel).
One People- There is only one people of God for all time who know their Creator only through one person- Jesus Christ.
One Path (of interpretation)- The New Testament primarily interprets Old Testament.
So in conclusion, if you can remember these six principle (NCT's principle of: interpretation, separation [of Old and New Covenant], unification [of salvation], progression [of Revelation], application [of law], representation) as we go through a more detailed look at NCT it will do you well. It should keep your thougths organized.
The next posts will follow my traditional outline of the various systems of theology. We will look at some definitions of NCT, some distinctions, and some dissection.
Trying to Focus on the Centrality of Jesus Christ in All Things,
Pastor Andy
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Summarizing New Covenant Theology (Part 2)
This post is a continuation of our summary look at New Covenant Theology that we began yesterday. NCT is different than the other two systems because it affirms rather robustly that Scripture, by nature, is progressive in its revelatory message. In other words, God has chosen, in His supreme wisdom, to reveal His plan of redemption through a revelatory process that does not give all the facts in one event. Instead, He has chosen to reveal fragments of truth at certain moments of history pertaining to His overall goal of redeeming an elect people for His glory.
There seems to be two major categories where the progression of God’s revelation can be seen. First, the Gospel itself is revealed in a progressive manner. Beginning in Genesis 3, and moving through redemptive history to the incarnation, crucifixion, resurrection, ascension, and the writings of the Apostles we find that the Gospel becomes clearer and clearer. Think of the confusion that the Apostles had during and even following Christ’s crucifixion. Think of all the Jewish/Gentile issues that the Apostle Paul wrote about. Think of the message of James (the half brother of our Lord) who wrote to clarify that the Gospel did not promote an idea of “cheap grace”- that faith without works is dead. Think about the complementary message of the Apostle John who said that love should reign supreme in the life of the one trusting and resting in Christ. In addition, we also should not forget the book of Acts, and all the issues (Jew/Gentile) that confronted the Jerusalem Council. Remember Peter who was even confused on the relationship between Jew and Gentile. Paul speaks about his confrontation with Peter over this very issue in the book of Galatians. The point is simply that the Gospel becomes clearer the further one moves in redemptive history. As one views the timeline of the Bible he sees that God's plan of redemption was not understood equally by God's people in all ages. The Apostles understood much more than the prophets. The believer's who made up the first century church under the Apostle Paul's ministry understood far more than the Patriarchs. We understand far more than Adam and Eve. NCT seems to recognize this more robustly than the other two systems.
NCT’S PRINCIPLE OF APPLICATION
As mentioned above, NCT clearly has a different position on “law” than the other two systems. It affirms a progressive revelation of God’s law. This fifth principle of NCT essentially argues that God’s law is applied differently to His people according to different points in redemptive history.
NCT simply does not view the Mosaic law as the unchanging, eternal, moral law of God. In other words, it is argued that God did not give His the law at Mt. Sinai in order to fully reveal Himself. Rather, He gave it to show man the exceeding sinfulness of man- to reveal his depravity. However, NCT does not deny, rather it affirms, that the Mosaic law contains elements of God’s absolute law. A distinction can be made between what is called “absolute” law and “covenantal” law. Absolute law refers to the law written on the heart of every human being (Romans 1) who is created in the image of God. Covenantal law refers to a particular revelation of God’s law that cannot change according to a particular covenant. In order for new law to come, a new covenant must come. The law and the covenant are bound up together.
So if believers today are not bound to Mosaic law, are they bound to law? Absolutely! However, it is not Mosaic law, nor do believers relate to this law the same as the nation of Israel did to their law (the ten commandments). The law of Christ, contained primarily in the New Testament Scriptures, is now in force for the church. But while the law of Christ reveals the standard of obedience for the new covenant believer, the new covenant believer is not related to this law in the same way that an old covenant believer (the nation of Israel) related to the law of Moses. The main reason for this is due to the indwelling of the Holy Spirit (more on this in later posts). The believer in the new covenant, in contrast to someone in the old covenant, has a desire to obey God and the ability to do so because of the Holy Spirit (Romans 8:1-16; Galatians 5:16-24; Hebrews 8:10, cf. Jeremiah 31:33). In addition, the law of Christ is not composed of legally binding and conditional stipulations.
Let me offer to you a comment by Fred Zaspel pertaining to the law that I will probably quote again at some point because it is so good:
“The law of God is always binding and could never be anything else. Before Moses there was no formal codification of it. Since Moses there have been differing codifications of it in accordance with covenantal relationships. The Old and New Covenants entail varying responsibilities, some of which are identical to each other (because of a common basis) and some exclusive of each other (because of fulfillment and further revelation). But the standard of conduct for today’s believers is found in the framework of New Covenant teaching, not that of the Old Covenant. To this rule of life He is bound as to law, and this law, like that of Moses, is sufficient to bring men ‘to an acknowledgement of their sins’”.
My only point under this fifth principle is simply that NCT sees the application of the law in the life of the believer as different depending upon the point in redemptive history.
Lord willing I will give the sixth principle on tomorrow’s post. I do not want to move too quickly. There is much in what I have said in this post to think about. The goal of these posts is not simply to disseminate information for "information's sake". Rather, the goal is to provide some thoughts on how Scripture fits together, so one can come to conclusions pertaining to this important topic that are based upon Scripture after careful, thoughtful, and sincere study. Everyone must be convinced in his own mind. But remember that God’s word is to richly dwell within us (Colossians 3:16). Our thinking must be saturated with Scripture!
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Summarizing New Covenant Theology
INTRONCT’S PRINIPLE OF INTERPRETATION
Let me make a few general comments. NCT teaches that the New Testament Scriptures must always interpret the Old Testament Scriptures. In other words, if one wants to understand the Old Testament, he must turn to the pages of the New Testament and read. An understanding of what the NT says about the OT renders a proper understanding of the OT. If we allow the OT to interpret the NT, then we run the risk of confusing the identity of both ethnic Israel and the church. This is what DT tends to do. On the other hand, if we only allow the NT to interpret the OT some of the time, then we run into the danger of being inconsistent in our overall interpretation of the Bible. This tends to be the propensity of CT. I strongly believe that when we allow the NT Scriptures to tell us the true meaning of the OT Scriptures, Christ holds a more central place in redemptive history.
NCT’S PRINCIPLE OF SEPARATION
Within NCT is a firm affirmation that the Old Covenant (Mosaic Covenant) is completely different in character to that of the New Covenant. There is strong separation between these two covenants. They stand in strong contrast to each other. And this fits in accordance with God’s overall sovereign plan of redemption. It is argued that Scripture always emphasizes the discontinuity between these covenants, not continuity, as CT proponents will argue.
NCT’S PRINCIPLE OF UNIFICATION
Lord willing, I will post the final three principles of NCT tomorrow.
Andy